Wednesday, December 08, 2004

An Interesting Discussion

Wanna read more Neo? Check out this post and thread on Worldmagblog about the performance of American public schools and its alternatives.

COMMENT POLICY

Please refrain from the use of foul language. Any failure to comply will result in comment deletion.

6 Comments:

At Wed Dec 08, 04:58:00 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Yes we have had our share of mishaps... so aggred with Ser... You could of let me know that it was happening when it was happening!... I would of loved to be a part of that one!... I'm a good debater, (or at least I think I am)when im passiate about somthing... Homeschooling is one of them... so next time tell earlier so that I can jump in! Please! Thank you

 
At Thu Dec 09, 05:42:00 PM, Blogger CFchampion said...

hey Neo, have you checked out that Jonathan Taylor Gatto book? I have the link on my blog... after reading that book... wow!

 
At Fri Dec 17, 08:54:00 PM, Blogger Dave Justus said...

Since V.F. was kind enough to link to my blog here it seems fair that I make some comments about home schooling.

First off, for some kids and some parents home schooling is a good fit. My sister home schools her children and while they are quite young yet they seem to be doing quite well.

I do think though that any comparision between home-schooled kids and non-homeschooled kids is probably comparing apples and oranges. Parents that care enough about their kids education to homeschool them would probably have kids who did very well in school whether they home-schooled them or not. It is probably impossible to say with numbers which environment they would learn more in.

I do get concerned about those parents who choose homeschooling because they feel that public schools are a 'bad environment' filled with 'evil.' They may be right, but I don't think that sheltering kids from the world is a good way to deal with that problem. I know that many homeschooled kids are not sheltered like this, but some are.

Lastly, I don't think that homeschooling is an effective solution for the nations educational problems as a whole. Their are several reasons for this. One is that their seems to be an obvious connection between parents who don't place much importance on education and children who do poor in school. Having these parents teach their children will likely increase the problem of uneduated kids rather than decrease it.

Equally important perhaps, is that specialization is central to a highly performing economy. Specialized teachers who can teach a group of kids at once (yes this is a more difficult task than just teaching a few kids) are a part of this, freeing up people to focus on what they are specialized at doing.

 
At Fri Dec 17, 08:56:00 PM, Blogger Dave Justus said...

For these reason's it seems to me that even homeschoolers and those who support homeschooling would be wise to examine ways to improve the public education system.

Lesson's learned from the homeschooling expirience might be a benefit here.

 
At Fri Dec 17, 11:29:00 PM, Blogger jacob.thrasher said...

Dave,

Interesting points, and I agree with you on most points. The following is the only part of your comment that I disagree with:

"I do get concerned about those parents who choose homeschooling because they feel that public schools are a 'bad environment' filled with 'evil.' They may be right, but I don't think that sheltering kids from the world is a good way to deal with that problem. I know that many homeschooled kids are not sheltered like this, but some are."

My main disagreement is with the statement about "sheltering" kids. Honestly, "the world" that you speak of, which would actually be public school, has absolutely nothing to do with real life. When kids grow up, they will use none of the so-called "social skills" that they learn in school.

As adults, they won't have nearly the amount of peer pressure to conform. When you're an adult, originality and intelligence are valued, not looked down upon. The training that kids receive in public schools today tends to inhibit their personal growth and it essentially teaches them to work towards mediocrity.

Allow me to clarify myself: I'm not against the idea of public schooling. I'm against the horrid state that our public schools are in. The kids aren't supervised in their socialization NEARLY enough, and they aren't taught even basic manners.

If the public school system actually did a half-way decent job, I wouldn't mind it, and I don't disagree with public schooling in principle. I simply believe that the job they are doing is just pathetic... way too many kids have a head knowledge of academic subjects, but can't think critically to save their lives. Moreover, they can't socialize like civilized human beings.

So essentially, I say keep the public school system. But for goodness sake, SOMEBODY FIX IT!

 
At Wed Dec 22, 09:42:00 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

I'm popular

 

Post a Comment

<< Home

All that is necessary for the triumph of evil is for good men to do nothing.


Take the MIT Weblog Survey Federal Social Security Calculator

Powered by Blogger

Who Links Here Religion Blog Top Sites Whose values?